Search This Blog

Saturday, 20 December 2025

Making good return in share market requires good education background?

Most of my colleagues are PhD holders.

I am not exaggerating. Indeed, they are PhD holders from reputable universities in Australia, UK, Japan and Singapore. I am a PhD holder too. But, due to certain reasons, I do not have the luxury to graduate from overseas. We share a common interest though, i.e. share market.

We often talk about the companies that we invested in during lunch hour. Due to the illiquid market condition in Bursa Malaysia, most of my colleagues chose to invest in the US market, which is rather common during the time of writing (hopefully it would change in the near future). Well, I am not saying that US market is not worth for investment at all; however, as soon as I know the counters my colleagues have invested, I am puzzled, and wordless.

For them, the primary reason to invest in the US market is liquidity. Fast in fast out, that's the key. As long as the counter is liquid and if it fits the hot investment themes to date (i.e., AI, data center, clean energy, etc.), they would go for it, regardless of valuation. For example, they would invest their money in those companies at a high double-digit PE ratio (or even triple digit) just because of the company has painted a beautiful picture that fits the current hot investment themes. Reading the financial statements of the company & find out the intrinsic value of the company?? Well, no need, according to them.

So far, they have made quite a good money though, by following their strategy. Some of them could make a handsome profit of almost 20%-30% within just a few months time. 

In 2025, I start to wonder whether my existing investment strategy, i.e. buy a good company below its intrinsic value and hold until the share price exceeds its intrinsic value, is working. The value of my portfolio shrinks by around 10%, partly due to the fact that a blue-chip company that I've invested heavily has been experiencing a sharp drop in share price (with no fundamental reason). Another reason is another company of mine, a F&B company, where one of the key management team members had been remanded by MACC, causing its share price to plunge. I have lost 5 digits on that counter alone as I have decided to sell the shares at a lost (lost faith to the company). 

So, at the first glance, my colleagues who'd graduated from those renowned universities, have indeed outperformed me in terms of investment return in 2025. Getting a profit of 20% - 30% is just a piece of cake, according to them. 

I started to reflect on the counters that I've invested in. Fundamentally, they are intact. Their core profits are growing, and there are no reasons for me to sell them, according to my investment standard. I talked to an investment guru in Bursa, who has made a 8-digit wealth from the share market after 20 years. I am quite relief that even an experienced investor like him is making a loss in 2025. We share a common investment philosophy though, i.e. never chase hot thematic counters at unreasonable price. Therefore, I guess my underperformance in 2025 is mainly due to the nature of my counters, where none of them are related to those hot themes such as construction, data center, solar energy, and AI.

 

Some stories:

Sir Isaac Newton, a renowned scientist, had lost money in the stock market by getting caught in the 1720 South Sea Bubble, giving in to greed and FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) after making early profits; he sold, then bought back in at the peak, only to see the speculative stock collapse, losing significant wealth due to emotional trading rather than sound analysis.

Warren Buffet, a legendary investor from the US, once said during his interview at Georgetown University: "Share investment does not need high IQ. If you have IQ of 160, sell 30 to others, you do not need it. Temperament is more important than intellect for investors".

 

I decided to stick to my existing investment strategy. It is painful to see the plunging value of my portfolio. Who loves it, right? But, I know my strategy would work, in long term....... Investment is a long journey and patience is the key to survive in the market. At the time of writing on Dec 2025, my portfolio turns green finally at around 1%. It is not up to my expectation yet, however, I believe it will.

So, does making good return in share market require good education background? Well, the investment story of Sir Isaac Newton has told us the answer, isn't it?

 


Friday, 19 December 2025

DKSH proposed privatization at RM6.15 - Fair deal?

Again, another low-profile company in Bursa Malaysia, DKSH Malaysia Berhad, is looking for delisting.

 

The major shareholder, DKSH Holding Ltd. via its subsidiary DKSH Resources (Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd. plans to privatize the company at RM6.15 per share, via the Share Capital Reduction (SCR).

 

When I received this privatization deal from the DKSH’s largest shareholder, frankly speaking, I have mixed feelings about this news.

I am happy because I could liquidate my DKSH stocks. Meanwhile....

I am sad because I might not be able to enjoy the subsequent growth phase of DKSH, after DKSH reported very strong Q3-2025 quarter earnings.

 

A very minor shareholder like me, of course, has no bargaining power about the plan. After all, my stake portion in DKSH is simply too insignificant to have any major impact on the ultimate decision made during the upcoming EGM. However, the 2nd largest shareholder of DKSH, i.e., Pangolin Asia Fund, could have some bargaining power on this privatization offer.

 

Pangolin Asia Fund holds about 4.3 million DKSH shares, representing about 2.71% of total DKSH shares issued (~158 million shares). The largest shareholder DKSH Resources (Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd., the one that intends to privatize DKSH at RM 6.15/share, holds ~117 million shares. In other words, Pangolin holds 10.6% of total minority shares, which is more than enough to vote against the privatization offer via SCR. Note that SCR exercises to take a company private require high thresholds (often ≥75% approval and ≤10% rejection among minorities).

 

Recently, Pangolin has openly rejected the offer (Source: https://www.enanyang.my/news/20251213/Finance/1101091). In short, if Pangolin votes against the offer during EGM, story ends and privatization fails. And, DKSH share price might fall to the pre-offer level, around RM 5.2+.

 

A pain for minor shareholder, isn't it?

 

Now, let us look into the reason why Pangolin Asia Fund rejects the offer.

Well, it is all about valuation. Pangolin argued that the offer price does not reflect the full potential of DKSH Malaysia (which I agree totally). Pangolin believes that in 10 years’ time, DKSH might trade at around 15x PER, as the company is growing and might attract more liquidity to the stock. Let us delve into the earning power of DKSH (see below), which is impressive as both revenue and profit are growing since year 2020, thanks to their operational efficiency and market expansion effort (consistently securing new clients in both the consumer & healthcare sectors).

 

Now, back to the opinion of Pangolin that DKSH could trade at 15x in 10 years’ time. For me, frankly speaking, the chance is rather slim. DKSH is a good company all this while, but why not many peoples bother to even look at it? Well, I think the main reason is the low liquidity of the stock (low-profile company), and the company is not operating in “sexy” themes like AI, data centre and stuffs like that. Other small fund managers would not dare to buy in as it could be hard for them to exit later. Plus, the dividend is not that high (at least at the current moment) that can attract those dividend-seekers to buy the stock.

 

Of course, I am not denying that DKSH should trade at higher PE multiple. It should. That’s the reason why I am accumulating the stocks since 2022. However, coming to the reality of market perception, it is quite challenging for DKSH to enjoy a fair PE multiple (at least the same as its peers in F&B and healthcare industries) considering all the constraints I mentioned above, isn’t it? The same story goes to another favourite stock of mine, HLFG.

 

In fact, the story of DKSH privatization via SCR is quite alike to the privatization deal of Selangor Properties Berhad (SPB) in 2018. During that time, again, the same (and vocal) minor shareholder Pangolin Asia Fund rejected the first offer in public (Source: https://theedgemalaysia.com/article/dissenting-voices-selangor-properties-privatisation-offer). What happened next? Let us look at the timeline below:

 

Oct 2018: Offer Price RM5.70 (rejected by Pangolin in public)

Dec 2018: Offer Price revised to RM 6.00

Jan 2019: Offer Price revised to RM 6.30 (accepted during EGM in Feb 2019)

 

Could the same price revision of SPB happen to DKSH?

Well, I am not sure though. It could, if the offeror (DKSH Resources Malaysia Sdn. Bhd.) is very desperate to delist the company. If not, they might just abandon their plan and life moves on.

 

For me, personally, the offer price is very close to my calculated intrinsic value of the company, based on the current earning level of DKSH. Of course, if DKSH’s business growth persists, it should worth more than the current offer price of RM 6.15. But who could read the future?

 

To minimize the risk, I will sell a minor portion of my stake in DKSH. The remaining portion of my stake, hopefully, could be sold at a higher price if the take-over price is revised (hopefully).


Monday, 18 August 2025

Is HLBANK/HLFG Really That Giam Siap?




I always like to ask my friends which bank stocks they would buy in Malaysia. Most of the time, the answers are the same: Maybank, Public Bank, CIMB, or RHB.


Then I ask, “Eh, how about Hong Leong Bank (HLBANK)?” Straight away, the comments come:

  • Aiya, the boss too giam siap lah (means stingy in Hokkien dialect).
  • Wah, price so high somemore — around RM19+. One biji (1 biji = 100 shares) already nearly RM1,900 leh! (typical retail mindset).


So I push further: “Then would you consider Hong Leong Financial Group (HLFG)?”

They just laugh and say: “HLFG? Even more giam siap than HLBANK!”


I believe most retail investors share the same mindset as my friends à HLBANK and HLFG are never on their list of investment choices. The typical reasons? Low dividend payout ratio and low dividend yield.


For retail investors (and even some fund managers), the priority is securing a steady, high-dividend income stream. That’s why when it comes to banking stocks, they naturally prefer banks with higher dividend yields, while bank asset quality often becomes a secondary concern.

 

But has anyone stopped to wonder why HLBANK/HLFG pays out relatively lower dividends compared to other banks? Is it really because the boss is stingy and doesn’t want to share profits with minority shareholders as my friends like to claim? If that’s true, then why does the very same boss, who controls HLBANK/HLFG, allow such high dividends in other of his/her companies like Hong Leong Industries (HLIND)? For reference, HLIND’s dividend payout was above 56 % since FY 2020 (reaching 87% in FY2024, including the special dividend).

 

To understand why HLBANK gives a relatively low dividend, perhaps it is good to look at a key capital ratio in banking industry, i.e. the CET-1 ratio, defined as:

 

CET-1 ratio = CET-1 capital / Risk-Weighted Assets (RWA)

 

Simply put, a higher CET-1 ratio means the bank has a stronger capital buffer and better ability to withstand an economic crisis. Retained earnings form part of CET-1 capital, and these are calculated after deducting dividends from net profit.

 

Now, what about Risk-Weighted Assets (RWA)? In simple terms, they represent the loans disbursed to customers, adjusted for their riskiness. Since lending always carries the risk of default, banks must hold sufficient capital against these loans.

 

In Malaysia, banks are required by BNM to maintain a minimum CET-1 ratio of 7.0% (4.5% minimum + 2.5% Capital Conservation Buffer). Put another way, a higher CET-1 ratio means the bank has more cushion, either by keeping more capital on hand or by controlling the size of its RWA (lending less).

 

Good news: All Malaysia banks are well above the regulatory requirement of BNM as shown in Table 1 below. Our banks are indeed well capitalized.

 

But how exactly does dividend payout tie in with the CET-1 ratio? Well, BNM requires banks to maintain at least 7%. If a bank is currently sitting at, say, 15% (almost double the requirement), it means the bank can afford to pay out more dividends. Of course, that reduces retained earnings → lowers CET-1 capital → and brings down the CET-1 ratio. But even then, the ratio would still be comfortably above BNM’s minimum, right?

 

Let us have a look in the CET-1 ratio on several banks in Malaysia (extracted from their 2024/2025 Annual Report) shown in Table 1 below:


Table 1: Key metrics for Malaysian banks (2024/2025)



RHB Bank has the highest CET-1 ratio and hence it could afford to declare a dividend payout of 60%, which is amazing. Meanwhile, Alliance Bank has the lowest CET-1 ratio, which could be attributed to the double-digit loan growth of 12% in 2024. Still, it declared a dividend payout of 40%, which is quite impressive. However, to preserve the CET-1 ratio at a comfortable level, Alliance Bank would need additional capital. This may be the reason why the Bank recently offered a rights issue to its shareholders.

 

How about Hong Leong Bank (HLBANK)? Its loan growth looks solid at 7.3% in FY2024, and yet its bad loans (GIL ratio) are among the lowest in the industry. The only catch is its CET-1 ratio — at 13.3%, which is slightly below the bigger banks.

 

Why lower? Mainly because HLBANK grew loans faster (which increases RWA) than its larger peers, plus it injected capital into its associate, i.e., Bank of Chengdu (BoCD) in China (note: HLBANK holds 17.8% stake in BoCD). To keep its CET-1 ratio at a relatively comfortable level, the bank has to retain more earnings, rather than paying more dividends from the net profit. That’s why its dividend payout is only around 33%, much lower than its peers.

 

The good news is, under the new Basel rules, the capital ratios of certain banks are expected to look stronger, and HLBANK’s management has hinted they may raise dividend payout closer to peers in the future. The new Basel rules would concentrate on the calculation of RWA, as the Basel Committee highlighted a worrying degree of variability in banks’ calculation of their RWA. The new Basel framework aims to restore credibility in those calculations by constraining banks’ use of internal risk models à some internal risk models give banks the most freedom to estimate their credit risk of RWA, often yielding a much lower risk (hence CET-1 ratio rises) than the regulator’s standard model. Hence, some banks that rely heavily on “internal models” to calculate their credit risk may see changes to their capital ratios once the new rules kick in, and that could affect their future dividends payout.

 

How about Hong Leong Financial Group (HLFG)? HLFG is essentially a holding company — it owns shares in Hong Leong Bank (HLBANK), Hong Leong Capital (HLCAP), and HLA Holdings (insurance arm). Naturally, its dividend payout depends on what it receives from these subsidiaries.


Table 2: Total dividends contributed by HLFG subsidiaries in FY 2024 (in RM)



Looking at FY2024 (see Table 2), HLFG declared total dividends of about RM620 million, which means it distributed almost 65% of the dividends it received to shareholders. The tricky part is HLA Holdings, which is unlisted, so its dividend contribution isn’t publicly available. But if we assume HLA Holdings paid out 50% of its FY2024 profit after tax (RM511m) as dividends to HLFG, then the effective payout to HLFG shareholders still comes up to around 51% of total dividends received from its subsidiaries.

 

So, is HLFG really “giam siap” and unwilling to share profits with minority shareholders?

Honestly, it depends on how you look at it. Some investors might only consider HLFG generous if it paid out 100% of what it receives. But in practice, retaining part of the earnings/dividends gives the group more flexibility to reinvest, support subsidiaries, and preserve capital buffers.