Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Investment thoughts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Investment thoughts. Show all posts

Tuesday, 23 December 2025

Why value investing is simple but difficult?

All of us know Warren Buffet, the iconic figure of value investing.

Warren Buffet always share his ways of investing in public. The whole world knows about his method of investing. Nothing secretive about it. 

But, why general public is unable to replicate his investing style, and success?

Before answering this question, let me talk about exercise.

All of us know exercise is good for health. But, out of 100 peoples, how many of them exercise regularly? I do not have the exact number, but I guess the number is not many, at least from my group of friends who seldom exercise. Rather, most people would take supplements to stay healthy. Easier and faster, according to them.

Let me make an analogy:

Exercise = Value Investing

Health = Making money

Taking supplements = Speculation, hit-and-run


Exercise needs perseverance, patience to succeed.

Most peoples cannot bear with the enormous time and effort needed to make money in stock market. A faster technique is more attractive for them.

That's the reason why most people would end up becoming a speculator, chasing hot thematic stocks to make fast money. They earn big, and may lost big too.


So, is value investing (exercise) difficult for you?




When to buy, when to sell?

 

I must admit that I seldom read books all this while.

But thing starts to change from year 2020 (MCO time) onwards, where I have spent time reading a lot of stock investment books. In fact, I started investing since year 2009. However, I seldom spend time in looking for undervalued stocks, not to mention the methods to determine the intrinsic value of a stock. Therefore, my portfolio hardly grows before year 2020.

 

In 2020, I have read a book entitled “Value Investing in Growth Companies” written by Rusmin and Victor, which has inspired me a lot.

 

The basic (yet key) questions of any investor are:

 

When to buy a stock?

When to sell a stock?

 

Rusmin and Victor have put forward a very simple way to answer the questions above. That is, PUZZLE.

 

The decision to buy/sell a stock is dependent on the availability of 4 puzzles. 

These 4 puzzles are:

Business

(Is business doing good in long term?)

 

Management

(Is the management team capable and reliable?)

 

Number

(Is the profit growing? Cash flow good?)

 

Valuation

(Is it cheap? Buy at discounted price please.)

 

So…

Question 1: When to buy a stock?

Answer: The 4 puzzles above are intact.

 

Question 2: When to sell a stock?

Answer: Either one of the 4 puzzles is broken.

 

I will remind my daughters on these puzzles.

Saturday, 20 December 2025

Making good return in share market requires good education background?

Most of my colleagues are PhD holders.

I am not exaggerating. Indeed, they are PhD holders from reputable universities in Australia, UK, Japan and Singapore. I am a PhD holder too. But, due to certain reasons, I do not have the luxury to graduate from overseas. We share a common interest though, i.e. share market.

We often talk about the companies that we invested in during lunch hour. Due to the illiquid market condition in Bursa Malaysia, most of my colleagues chose to invest in the US market, which is rather common during the time of writing (hopefully it would change in the near future). Well, I am not saying that US market is not worth for investment at all; however, as soon as I know the counters my colleagues have invested, I am puzzled, and wordless.

For them, the primary reason to invest in the US market is liquidity. Fast in fast out, that's the key. As long as the counter is liquid and if it fits the hot investment themes to date (i.e., AI, data center, clean energy, etc.), they would go for it, regardless of valuation. For example, they would invest their money in those companies at a high double-digit PE ratio (or even triple digit) just because of the company has painted a beautiful picture that fits the current hot investment themes. Reading the financial statements of the company & find out the intrinsic value of the company?? Well, no need, according to them.

So far, they have made quite a good money though, by following their strategy. Some of them could make a handsome profit of almost 20%-30% within just a few months time. 

In 2025, I start to wonder whether my existing investment strategy, i.e. buy a good company below its intrinsic value and hold until the share price exceeds its intrinsic value, is working. The value of my portfolio shrinks by around 10%, partly due to the fact that a blue-chip company that I've invested heavily has been experiencing a sharp drop in share price (with no fundamental reason). Another reason is another company of mine, a F&B company, where one of the key management team members had been remanded by MACC, causing its share price to plunge. I have lost 5 digits on that counter alone as I have decided to sell the shares at a lost (lost faith to the company). 

So, at the first glance, my colleagues who'd graduated from those renowned universities, have indeed outperformed me in terms of investment return in 2025. Getting a profit of 20% - 30% is just a piece of cake, according to them. 

I started to reflect on the counters that I've invested in. Fundamentally, they are intact. Their core profits are growing, and there are no reasons for me to sell them, according to my investment standard. I talked to an investment guru in Bursa, who has made a 8-digit wealth from the share market after 20 years. I am quite relief that even an experienced investor like him is making a loss in 2025. We share a common investment philosophy though, i.e. never chase hot thematic counters at unreasonable price. Therefore, I guess my underperformance in 2025 is mainly due to the nature of my counters, where none of them are related to those hot themes such as construction, data center, solar energy, and AI.

 

Some stories:

Sir Isaac Newton, a renowned scientist, had lost money in the stock market by getting caught in the 1720 South Sea Bubble, giving in to greed and FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) after making early profits; he sold, then bought back in at the peak, only to see the speculative stock collapse, losing significant wealth due to emotional trading rather than sound analysis.

Warren Buffet, a legendary investor from the US, once said during his interview at Georgetown University: "Share investment does not need high IQ. If you have IQ of 160, sell 30 to others, you do not need it. Temperament is more important than intellect for investors".

 

I decided to stick to my existing investment strategy. It is painful to see the plunging value of my portfolio. Who loves it, right? But, I know my strategy would work, in long term....... Investment is a long journey and patience is the key to survive in the market. At the time of writing on Dec 2025, my portfolio turns green finally at around 1%. It is not up to my expectation yet, however, I believe it will.

So, does making good return in share market require good education background? Well, the investment story of Sir Isaac Newton has told us the answer, isn't it?